Episode 12: LNG Panel Operations

Richard Jones
Hello, everyone and welcome back to the LNG Academy.  

I’m your host, Richard Jones, Chief Operating Officer at Capstone ITS and proudly part of the Solaris Group of companies.  

In today’s episode, we’ll cover a topic that is paramount to the safe and efficient operations of LNG facilities worldwide, LNG panel operations. This episode is brought to you by Gastech 2024, the world’s largest meeting place for natural gas, LNG, hydrogen, low carbon solutions and climate technologies. 

This year, Gas Tech will take place at the George R Brown Convention Center in Houston, TX from September 17th through 20th. 

And I’m happy to share that representatives from Capstone ITS as well as our Solaris group of companies will be in attendance. 

OK, let’s jump into today’s LNG panel operations episode.  

Joining me today is my colleague Mehdy Touil, a regular Co-host of LNG Academy and an LNG operations Specialist with the Capstone ITS team. 

Hi Mehdy. 
 

Mehdy Touil 
Hi Richard. 
 

Richard Jones 
Mehdy, your career in global LNG is approaching the 20-year mark with most of that time in an LNG panel operator role. 

The term panel operator might be unclear even to professionals in other sectors of the LNG industry. 

Can you elaborate on what that role entails?

 

Mehdy Touil 
I get this question quite often and the term can be indeed confusing. 

An LNG operator at a liquefaction plant, at a trading office or at the shipping desk are totally different roles. 

To this day I still receive job offers for a commercial role that contains the term LNG operator in the title. 

The LNG panel operator function is also known as the control room operator, the board, the console operator, the CCR operator for central control room or simply DCS operator for distributed control system. 

They all mean the same thing for people outside the industry. 

I like to use the railway analogy. 

A panel operator is a train driver. 

 

The driver is in charge of the mechanical operation of the train, the train speed and all the train handling. 

The panel operator is in charge of the production line called an LNG train, which consists of units arranged in sequence for the processing, treatment and liquefaction of natural gas. 

 

Richard Jones 
Thanks, Mehdy. 

I appreciate the railway analogy as part of the interconnected equipment relationship of the term train across both industries. 

For those interested in becoming LNG panel operators, can you explain how the progression from field operator to a panel operator typically happens and speak to what kind of training and experience are required to make that transition? 

 

Mehdy Touil 
The journey from field operator to control room operator is a significant progression that will require a blend of experience, training and aptitude. 

Typically a field operator start by start by working directly on the LNG plants equipment. 

This hands-on experience is crucial. 

 

It provides an in-depth understanding of the machinery and processes involved in LNG production, including start up and shut down of individual units. 

The next logical steps before becoming a panel operator is the role of a senior operator. 

As a senior operator, you become in charge of a group of field operators, overseeing their work and ensuring that all processes are running smoothly. 

Over time, operators undergo rigorous training programs that cover both theoretical and practical aspects of LNG operations. 

This includes learning about the distributed control system, the safety protocols, emergency procedures and the process optimization. In addition to formal training, so mentoring from experienced panel operators in invaluable. 

This on-the-job training helps field operator understand the nuances of monitoring and controlling the plant operation from within the control room. 

They learn how to translate data, troubleshoot issues, and make real time decisions to ensure the smooth and safe operation of the LNG train. 

There is also a vetting process that usually involves the shift supervisor opinion, input from existing panel operators, and comprehensive sessions on the LTS simulator. 

This is a key position where mistakes can potentially cost millions of dollars in production losses or damaged equipment. 

So it’s critical to ensure you put the right person in front of the screen. 

It takes several years of field experience and comprehensive training before an operator is ready to transition into the control room. 
 

This ensure that they have the necessary knowledge and confidence to manage the complex and critical tasks of a panel operator. 

 

Richard Jones 
That’s fascinating, Mehdy. 

Thanks for sharing those insights. 

Given the level of responsibility and the rigorous process to become an LNG panel operator, would you say the panel operator position is a coveted one within the LNG industry? 

 

Mehdy Touil 
Not always Richard, the position comes with a high level of stress and not everyone is cut out for handling an LNG train on the verge of tripping in a multibillion-dollar facility. 

Personally, I was I was not particularly excited about the idea of sitting for 12 hours in front of a multi-screen setup. 

It took a lot of convincing from my peers and my supervisor before I accepted the challenge. 

And let me tell you, it was not love at first sight. 

Many of my colleagues decided to pass on the opportunity and continue working in the field despite the limited progression prospects. 

The reality is that the best operator in the field does not necessarily make the best panel operator. 

So field operations require a hands-on approach, physical presence and direct interaction with the equipment. 

It’s a very dynamic and physically engaging role. 

On the other hand, panel operations require a require a different set of skills such as the ability to monitor complex systems, make quick and accurate decisions based on data, and handling high stress situations, while maintaining your composure. 

It’s a role that demands a lot of mental focus and the ability to work well under pressure in a more isolated and controlled environment. 

Throughout my career, I have met excellent panel operators who were not particularly outstanding in the field. 

They thrived more in the control room setting where the analytical skills and ability to process information quickly made them invaluable. 
 

On the opposite, some of the best field operators I know choose to remain in their roles because they preferred the hands-on nature of the job and the direct impact they could see from their efforts. 

 

Additionally, being continuously monitored in the control room by your supervisor, the Superintendent, or the management is not something everyone is cut out for. 

In essence, both roles are crucial but require different strengths. 

It’s not a matter of one being better than the other, but rather finding where one’s skills and preferences align best. 

 

Richard Jones 
Thanks Mehdy. 

I can certainly appreciate how the LNG panel operator role needs to work in concert with other facility resources to ensure safe and viable operations. 

What is the most challenging part of being an LNG panel operator? 

 

Mehdy Touil 

The most challenging part, Richard, is with no doubt the physical toll and the health impact that comes with the job. 

Sitting for 12-hour shifts in front of multiple screens can be incredibly taxing on the body. 

The long hours of continuous focus and limited physical movement can lead to various health issues, especially during intense periods like trips, shutdowns or start-ups. 

I think we are not there yet in terms of support from the LNG industry. 

While there have been significant improvements in ergonomics, lighting quality, display technology, control room design, the reality is that sitting for 12 hours straight is never recommended no matter how much you claim to exercise during your off days. 

We need to have an honest, frank discussion around this issue that would involve scientific research. 

During my time as a panel operator, I would call my senior operator to replace me during my lunch or dinner break so I could take a short walk to relax my legs and my back. 

However, this was not an official arrangement but more of a necessity.  

Despite these efforts, the high stress environment and the physical demands can lead to burnout, anxiety and other health issues if not managed properly. 

It’s crucial for panel operators to take care of their physical and mental well-being, but it’s also vital for the industry to provide more comprehensive support and solutions. 

 

Richard Jones 
I appreciate you reminding us of the human health aspects related to this role, Mehdy. 

Considering the challenges you’ve spoken to, is the LNG panel operator position looked upon as a long-term position? 

 

Mehdy Touil 
It takes many years of operating the DCS to acquire enough experience to become truly comfortable at the console and everyone of course progresses at their own pace. 

There is also significant difference between a panel operator who has witnessed commissioning start up in the first two years of the tedious troubleshooting that characterized the beginning of any liquefaction project, and the panel operators has only experienced steady state operations or the occasional trip twice or three times a year. 

Those initial years are incredibly challenging but also invaluable for building deep expertise. 

The experience gained during commissioning startup phases is critical because you encounter and resolve a wide range of issues. 

This knowledge is something you carry with you and that shapes your ability to handle future problems in an effective manner. 

On the other hand, someone who has experienced steady state operations only might not develop the same depth of problem-solving skills simply because they haven’t faced the same breadth of challenges. 

Of course both types of experiences are valuable, but the learning curve and the skill developed can be quite different. 

I would say that if after 10 years you are still on the panel, it might be time for you to move to a new project. 

It is easy to get trapped in the position because unfortunately if you are very good at DCS operations, your management will do its best to keep you in your seat. 

Of course, there are upper-level positions like Senior Panel Operator or what is called CCR Supervisor or Panel Officers in other companies, but those come with the same challenges for a modest increase in compensation. 

The LNG industry is steadily growing. 

There are a lot of large-scale facilities under construction or already approved across the globe. 

Experience panel operator with liquefaction experience are highly sought after. 

I always recommend to my colleagues to seek new projects to refresh their expertise and moving to a new project can provide new challenges, opportunities to learn and prevent burnout from the repetitive nature of the job. 

 

Richard Jones 
Thanks Mehdy. 

With the LNG industry continued growth in mind and us now having a clearer understanding of the importance of this role within an LNG facility, what comes after the LNG panel operator? 

 

Mehdy Touil 
Usually there are only two options, so either a promotion to a supervisor level or a horizontal move to become an OTS instructor or take another function within the training department. 

The training option is often seen as the easier way out since the supervisor positions are relatively limited. 

However, I don’t particularly like the training option. 

Even the best panel operators are not necessarily the best trainers or mentors, but most companies favor this path to retain talent or simply to reward the most senior employees. 

On the other hand, supervisory roles come with their own set of challenges, but also offer more opportunities for growth and leadership. 

And in contrast, transitioning to training can sometimes mean moving away from the core operational challenges that many operate panel operators thrive on. 

Or if you like taking risks, do like I did and explore other segments of the industry. 

There is a whole new world waiting outside the control room. 

The LNG industry is vast and stepping into different roles can provide fresh perspectives and new challenges, which can be incredibly rewarding. 

I’m talking front end development, consulting, trading or exploring the exciting opportunities that AI will bring to our industry. 

This is the golden age of LNG. 

 

Richard Jones 

Thank you, Mehdy, and valid point regarding senior operators transitioning into training and mentorship roles. 

The assessment and validation and support of this type of role transition is certainly a process that the Capstone ITS team is familiar with and often engaged to review and advise upon with our clients. 

Mehdy, I’ve truly enjoyed covering today’s topic with you, and I’m grateful for the knowledge and insights that you’ve shared with us today regarding LNG panel operations. 

I’ve captured a lot of notes, and I believe there are several items related to the topics that we’ve covered today that we could possibly explore together within future LNG Academy episodes. 
On behalf of Mehdy and myself, thank you everyone for tuning into this episode and we’ll catch you on the next one.